Tuesday, July 10, 2012

A Scholarly Article, From A Reputable Source.

For my article assignment I choose to read and analyze, "Tattoos and Piercings: Attitudes, Behaviors, and Interpretations of College Students" by Jenn Horne from Alabama in association with the College Student Journal.

The article begins by giving examples on the dichotomy between the opinions of college age males and females who have either tattoos or piercings. According to Jenn it seems the majority of college students are women and largely contribute in the stigma of tattoos, while more men condition the stigmas of piercings. This is supported by a continued elaboration of percentages. She makes clear that the numbers are a collaboration of both those with and without body art and that the results may reflect biased opinions.

As it goes on Jenn begins to discuss the behavior of those with tattoos and piercings. Again, by comparing the attitudes of both men and women, it seems that women view the ideology of tattoos as being more as a statement of beauty or artistic expression. Men seem to view tattoos as symbolism, and this article suggests that it is largely due to their role in the military. The majority of women got tattoos that were "girly" or to use a less sexist term, aesthetic, while men used both religious and cultural symbolism as a basis for their ideas.

While this article continues on into the behavior of body piercing in college students it states that men who have body piercings are not prone to "normative" behavior. She continues by suggesting that it is a statement of individualism or style; "goth." Of course, for women the idea is an expression of sexual identity? Anything as simple as fine jewelery to piercings far more suggestive.

It seems a large contributor to the stigma daunting piercings is in parents, as in previous generations the idea that piercings once gave was being apart of the homosexual community. This supposedly contributes to the lacking number of men with body jewelery, along with probable difficulties it may cause in the workplace by preventing one from having a professional look.

To conclude, Jenn rationalizes the relevancy of this information. In short; both college sexes were found to see body art as an attractive feature, and that a large number of these students had not considered the potential health consequences before their procedures. She explains that a great number of people with tongue piercings endured dental damage, and seems to end rather abruptly from there with statistic evidence of her claims followed promptly with a bibliography.

Anyway...

Do I agree with the research that was presented? Certainly not. First; the article is presented as a look into the attitude, behaviors and interpretations of college students on tattoos and piercings and it seems quite plainly that it is geared mainly toward the comparison between the view of sexes. It hardly consolidates the two to give a college "persons" view. From there this article is already flawed and has no solid purpose.

Second, it seems pretty clear to me that many of the "research" provided to back up her claims amounted to the census of a select group likely in a very small area. Because the author for the article is based in Alabama I can assume they made no effort to travel out of state for better results. The article was written in a professional manner. Sentences seem a little straight forward and unimaginative, but it is a fitting manor of speaking for this particular piece.

So what are the real world applications to this article?

I hope we can all agree that there should be a lot of thought behind altering our bodies in any permanent manor. How better can we understand the effects it will have in our own lives than to observe the opinions and view points of others, more specifically those of our age. If we can better understand the common positive and negative aspects of tattoos and piercings hopefully we can make more educated decisions when committing to alterations.

Body art is indeed a form of art and for many has psychologically positive aspects. There are plenty of reasons, from an emotional perspective, tattoos and piercings can effect our health. Speaking in an honest manor, this article was fairly uninteresting and I found it difficult to agree with any topic Jenn discussed. Without using larger ideas to solidify her research the article felt empty. I can say, however, that her article was disagreeable enough that it lead me into far larger ideas about the culture surrounding body art and that's a good a reason as any to make waves.... I guess.


"I choose this article because..." the assignment lacked specificity and I like being creative.
-Alex

(P.S. This took me a consistent week to write. It's this long for a reason. I can guess the effort will have been in vain... I mean, is she even going to read these? My name is count pope-ula, the magical monster from your backyard with pencils for arms. SKITTLES.)

Jenn Horne "Tattoos and piercings: attitudes, behaviors, and interpretations of college students". College Student Journal. FindArticles.com. 05 Jul, 2012.

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0FCR/is_4_41/ai_n27484190/?tag=content;col1

6 comments:

  1. I agree about body modification being a permanent thing in most cases, and that it is important to think about it before you go through with it. Anytime someone writes an article like this the results are only as limited as the sample they used. In this case like you said, the sample was most likely limited and therefore the opinions are going to be reflective of the region in which they were formed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Personally I never really take the time to think about the process or image of body art. Maybe it has become so normal to view that the individual artistic view is lost with me. (Sad, I know.) But I like that you encourage those who might be considering body art to really think it through. I agree it should be something of value to you at the end and that requires thought. You can tell you put a lot of energy and time into the article and I appreciate you sharing it with us!

    Ps. Your last line after your name was clever and silly :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the chick who wrote this article is weird. People have tattoos/piercings because they want to express themselves in a different way. They have a special meaning to that individual. Tattoos are permanent and definitely should be thought about before getting it on your body. I know I certainly did!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm glad you chose a topic I can actually relate to! haha. I agree that a large amount of time and consideration should be put into choosing a permanent body mod. Though it seems like a lot of young people are getting tattoos these days just to say they have them, I consider the whole process to be very special. My parents are not pleased with the 6 I've gotten thus far, but the self-esteem they have given me is one of the reasons I'm still around today.

    ReplyDelete
  5. People really do need to think before getting tattoos. I know too many people that have tattoos that they either are going to regret, or they already do regret. However, I think everyone gets body mods for different reasons. It's hard to try to say exactly why a whole society has fallen in love with them

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with Corbin, people really do need to think before getting tattoos. As young and wild adults, we think we can do anything without repercussion. For example that cute wrist tattoo will most likely stop you from getting certain jobs but we dont think about that... just some food for thought.

    ReplyDelete